Dance Houston must give kudos to the Houston Ballet
and Stanton Welch for continuing its annual free
performances in the Miller Outdoor Theatre! The
mission of Dance Houston is to create appreciation
for dance in Houston. Houston Ballet, by offering
free performances to any interested dance patron to
their always high-quality productions, shows a
similar commitment to broadening access to and
appreciation of the art of dance in Houston. As one
of the more expensive dance productions to see in
Houston, it is heartening to see that Houston Ballet
continues to reach a socio-economically diverse
audience, in part, through its continuation of
performances at the Miller Outdoor Theatre.
This May of 2008, Houston Ballet presented "Madame
Butterfly" at Miller Outdoor. While the
environmental conditions were unmistakably warm
outside, and the Miller stage differs quite
substantially from the Wortham, the dancers showed
no sign of perturbance with their unfamiliar
conditions. Rather, they presented a high quality
performance consistent with Houston Ballet's usual
professionalism.
The choice of the tale of "Madame Butterfly" was
an excellent one, as this poignant story of an
American sailor's disastrous temporary marriage to a
young Japanese geisha lends itself beautifully to
ballet format. Originally adapted from Puccini's
opera to a ballet in 1955 by Sir Frederick Ashton of
the Royal Ballet in London, Stanton Welch re-made
the production for the Australian Ballet in 1995.
Since its world premiere in Melbourne, various
companies around the world have adopted the ballet,
including Houston Ballet under Ben Stevenson's
tenure as Artistic Director in 2002. This work is
considered Welch's signature piece.
Opening with a gorgeous glimpse of Cio-Cio San
(a.k.a. Butterfly) in long, flowing robes, a
bejeweled headdress, and four giant wings, one can
immediately see that the costuming will be
spectacular. And it does live up to its promise,
particularly those costumes made for the Japanese
female characters comprised of airy chiffon, which
highlights the dancers' ethereal forms and delicate
grace as they move. Only once does the costuming
detract from the piece: the entire audience held its
breath during the wedding scene expecting San to
trip over her long robes (though thankfully skilled
artist Sara Webb did not).
The choreography for Madame Butterfly gave a
clear depiction of the story and did not require any
re-reads of the plot synopsis to understand the
goings-on on stage. Stanton Welch particularly
excelled at choreographing the pas de deux between
San and the sailor Pinkerton following the wedding,
demonstrating the transition from awkwardness to
passion between the newlywed (and newly met) couple.
Welch, in particular, created several spectacular
lifts, including one where Pinkerton throws San into
a double turn in the air and then, instead of
catching her, allows her to almost hit the ground,
until - at the last possible moment - he grabs her
arm while her legs are in a stag position and swings
her around him. The audience gasped with suspense
during this lift.
Though Welch demonstrates proficiency in his
choreography for duets, he, however, lacks a bit in
his ability to manage choreography for a corps de
ballet. He clearly hears and wants the audience to
see several themes in the music, and, as such, often
has his dancers move in canonical style or in
complicated interweaving patterns. He might be able
to pull off this complex choreography if his dancers
were perfectly in sync, but unfortunately, they were
not. (I recall as a young girl watching Ben
Stevenson lining up his corps dancers on the Wortham
stage and taking out a measuring tape to check their
synchronicity and alignment. At the time, I thought
it an extreme measure, but I see the benefit now.)
By utilizing such complex patterns, Welch misses the
beauty that can be found in the simplicity of having
the dancers in sync - even if it is only for a few
seconds here and there. An intelligent choreographer
hears all the patterns in the music and puts his
steps together accordingly; a genius choreographer
hears the patters and finds the simplest means to
show them to his or her audience. With that said,
"Madame Butterfly" was Welch's first full-length
ballet, so without a doubt he has gained more
experience working with and choreographing for a
stage full of people.
The two dancers of note during this performance
were the female lead, Sara Webb, who played San, and
Jessica Collado, who played Pinkerton's wife, Kate.
Webb gave the role of the Japanese geisha the
delicacy and vulnerability it required. She has a
gorgeous smile - somewhat evocative of former
Houston Ballet prima ballerina, Janie Parker - which
endeared her greatly to the audience. There were
times in the ballet, though, when her beaming smile
was more than the role required, particularly at the
beginning of the pas de deux with Pinkerton, when
the choreography and music called for a more
reserved persona.
Soloist Jaquel Andrews, however, stole the show
as Kate, Pinkerton's American wife. Andrews, of all
the dancers onstage - including the males - had by
far the greatest vitality of movement. Her ability
to contrast sharp and soft movements, all in perfect
time with the music and excellent technical form,
made her the stand-out performer of the evening. She
is without a doubt a dancer whose career has the
potential to take- off.
There may not be a better place to watch "Madame
Butterfly" than at Miller Outdoor Theatre. The
beautiful costumes and dancing onstage is only
rivaled by the shining stars overhead. It would
behoove Houston Ballet to continue its performances
there for many years to come.
by Amanda Austin